169th New York Yacht Club Annual Regatta: Menace leaves IC37 fleet fighting for second, twice
by New York Yacht Club 12 Jun 2023 14:31 NZST
June 9-11, 2023
169th NYYC Annual Regatta © Daniel Forster
Last year, Howard Spencer surprised more than a few people by flying with his crew from New Zealand, stepping onto an IC37 for the first time and winning his class debut in the Round the Island Race that traditionally kicks off the New York Yacht Club Annual Regatta. A respectable seventh, of 20, in the two-day weekend series that followed proved the initial victory wasn't a fluke. This year, Spencer and his Menace team doubled up on first-place trophies, winning Friday's shortened Round the Island Race and then taking the weekend series as well.
"It's a long way from the other side of the world," says Spencer. "[In the IC37 class] you have a better than fair chance of winning, the boats are pretty even—which is what you want in a one-design class. Being able to roll in here, pick up a boat, put some new sails on it and be competitive is fantastic."
After four solid races, Menace started the final race earlier today with a one-point lead over Steve Liebel's New Wave and a five-point lead over Peter McClennen's Gamecock. Both teams have tasted success in this class in the past. Covering one good team with the regatta on the line is a tall order, covering two can often be impossible.
"The last race today was the most terrific race," he says. "We got there somehow, we had two boats close behind [in the overall standings] and, trying to keep those two boats behind us, [tactician] Chris Steele did a great job there."
The New York Yacht Club's Annual Regatta was first sailed on the Hudson River on July 16 and 18, 1846. A similar competition the previous year was called a Trial of Speed. With a few exceptions for world wars and other global crises, the event has been held every year since. For the majority of its existence, the Annual Regatta was raced on waters close to New York City. Since 1988, however, the event has been sailed out of the Harbour Court clubhouse in Newport, R.I., and, in 2004, it settled into the current three-day format, which includes a race around Conanicut Island on Friday, two days of buoy or navigator-course racing on Saturday and Sunday and nightly social activities on the grounds of the historic Harbour Court mansion. The 169th Annual Regatta is sponsored by Hammetts Hotel, Safe Harbor Marinas, and Helly Hansen.
Final results for Friday's Around the Island Race are here.
Final results for the Weekend Series are here.
After starting the weekend series with a win, New York Yacht Club Commodore Paul Zabetakis and his team on Impetuous saw things turn for the worse in Saturday's second race in the 10-boat ORC C division.
"We had a bad race," he says. "We had a bad start and, basically, we were in last place."
Zabetakis and much of his team have sailed together for a decade or more and have weathered plenty of storms, literally and figuratively. No one likes to look up shortly after the start and see a fleet of transoms. But it happens to everyone at some point. How a team responds to the adversity is what really counts.
"We clawed ourselves back to fifth, which I think saved the regatta," says Zabetakis. "Today we were third coming in. We had two really good starts, and it got us out in good lanes so we were able to finish second and then first. Yesterday's bad race really set us up for today."
It's something that Zabetakis says he's seen before—his team rebounding from a poor race and winning the regatta on the final day. He attributes his team's resiliency to the fact that they all really enjoy sailing together.
"We found this thing that's almost a pattern," he says. "If we don't do well on a Saturday, then on Sundays we sort of come back. I think the team just gels, and we buckle down and get it done. I have a lot of fun with the team, everybody knows what to do. It's just amazing to watch them. They work well together; they like each other, and I think that's the secret."
In the 14-boat Shields class, a big comeback wasn't necessary for John Burnam and Reed Baer's Grace, but that shouldn't detract from their performance today. The team finished no lower than third in each of today's four races.
"Boat 258, Clay Deutsch's Tinky, sailed a great day yesterday and we were four points behind him," says Burnham. "He finished right behind us in the first race today, but there were no throw outs in this regatta, and he had a bad race and suddenly were ahead or maybe we were even going into the third race, then he had another tough race."
When all was said and done, Grace had turned a four-point deficit into a 15-point lead, easily the biggest margin of victory across the regatta.
"We were fast downwind, which bailed us out on the first day when I had some bad starts," says Burnham. "Then I have to tell you, the third race yesterday, the cover of our main sheet broke. We tried to tape it, then it got stuck in the block we couldn't let it out in the last race. Fortunately we were going the right way and everyone else went the wrong way. It was a weird race, we had no right to finish fourth in that race. That was the key race of the regatta."
What the 12-Metre Modern class lacked in numbers, it made up for in star power. Among the four entries were two former America's Cup-winning yachts and some of the top professional sailors in the world.
This weekend, Peter Askew's Enterprise team was the class of this elite group, winning Friday's Round the Island Race and then taking the first three races of the weekend series before showing a hint of mortality with a second in the regatta's final race. Takashi Okura's Freedom team, which included America's Cup legends Murray Jones and Grant Simmer in the afterguard, was second.
Sailing the heavy, historic 12 Metres represents a significant course change for Askew, who until a few years ago was involved with his brother David in an ocean-racing campaign onboard a terrifically fast Volvo 70. A short race was measured in hundreds of miles.
"[Sailing 12 Metres] kind of takes me back to how I learned how to sail as a kid, things were a lot slower and moved a bit differently back then," he says. "We got together with some of the guys I've been sailing with regularly and put a team together and started to develop the boat. We made some changes, it's been very fun. It's very technical and I like that part of it."
The true test for both teams will come later this summer as the 12 Metre class will host its world championship in July in Newport. Askew and his Enterprise team has won the initial battle, but the Freedom team will be gunning for revenge in a little over a month.
Final Results
Place, Yacht Name, Type, Owner/Skipper, Hometown, Results, Total Points
12 Metre - Modern (One Design - 4 Boats)
1. Enterprise (M), 12 Metre 66, USMMA Sailing Foundation, Key Largo, FL, USA - 1 -1 -1 -2; 5
2. Freedom, 12 Meter 63.5, Takashi Okura, Alpine, NJ, USA - 2 -2 -2 -1; 7
3. Courageous, 12 Meter 19.94, Oakcliff Sailing, Oyster Bay, NY, USA - 3 -3 -4 -3; 13
4. Defender, 12 Meter 68, Andrew Rose, Newport Beach, CA, USA - 4 -5 -3 -4; 16
ORC A (ORC - 1 Boats)
1. Bella Mente, Maxi 72 74, Hap Fauth, Naples, FL, USA - 1 -1 -1 -1; 4
ORC B (ORC - 5 Boats)
1. Prospector, TP52 52, Larry Landry Paul McDowell, Newport, RI, USA - 1 -4 -1 -1; 7
2. Interlodge IV, Botin 44 44, Gwen and Austin Fragomen, Newport, RI, USA - 2 -2 -2 -2; 8
3. Stark Raving Mad IX, Carkeek 47 47, Jim Madden, Newport Beach, CA, USA - 3 -1 -3 -5; 12
4. Temptation-Oakcliff-Youth, Ker 50 50, Arthur Santry, Oyster Bay, NY, USA - 4 -3 -5 -4; 16
5. Pterodactyl, R/P 45 45, Scott Weisman, White Plains, NY, USA - 5 -5 -4 -3; 17
ORC C (ORC - 10 Boats)
1. Impetuous, Swan 42 42.5, Paul Zabetakis, Jamestown, RI, USA - 1 -5 -2 -1; 9
2. Tio Loco, Club Swan 42 42.5, Henry Brauer Steve Madeira, Northeast Harbor, ME, USA - 5 -2 -4 -3; 14
3. Dark Storm, J 121 39.67, Ken Comerford, Annapolis, MD, USA - 3 -1 -6 -5; 15
4. Gemini II, Swan 45 45, James Coffman, Westport, CT, USA - 7 -6 -1 -2; 16
5. Vamoose, J 133 43, Bob Manchester, Barrington, RI, USA - 2 -3 -7 -4; 16
ORC E (ORC - 10 Boats)
1. The ROCC, J112e 36, Al Minella, Saint Petersburg, FL, USA - 1 -3 -1 -1; 6
2. Rima98, Italia 11.98 39, John Brim, Palm Beach, FL, USA - 3 -1 -2 -5; 11
3. Das Blau Max, Farr 30 30, Mark and Cory Sertl Sertl, Jamestown, RI, USA - 2 -2 -5 -2; 11
4. Defiance, Navy 44 44, 1/C Phil Pacheco, Annapolis, MD, USA - 7 -4 -3 -3; 17
5. Integrity, Navy 44 44, 1/C Aidan Johnson, Annapolis, MD, USA - 4 -5 -4 -6; 19
Classics 1 (CRF MkII - 6 Boats)
1. Onawa, 12 metre 69, Chris Culver, Newport, RI, USA - 1 -1; 2
2. BLACK WATCH, Custom Yawl 68, Austin Fragomen, Newport, RI, USA - 2 -2; 4
3. Gleam (V) (Spin), 12 Metre 69, Andrew Tyska, Bristol, RI, USA - 4 -3; 7
4. Intrepid, 12 Metre 65, Jack Curtin, Toronto, Ont, CAN - 3 -4; 7
5. Marilee, NY 40 65', Ken Colburn, Boston, MA, USA - 5 -5; 10
Classics 2 (CRF MkII - 5 Boats)
1. Bijou II, 30 Square Meter 40.35, Chris Bouzaid, CUSHING, ME, USA - 1 -3 -1; 5
2. Dorade, S&S 52 52.5, Matt Brooks, Fremont, CA, USA - 2 -1 -2; 5
3. Lively Lady, Carter Tina One Ton 36, William Hubbard, New York, NY, USA - 3 -2 -3; 8
4. Phantom, Concordia Yawl 41, Joshua Dennerlein, Westfield, NJ, USA - 4 -4 -6; 14
5. Angelita, 8 Metre 50.33, S Skelsey/Croll, Greenwich, CT, USA - 6 -6 -6; 18
PHRF 2 (PHRF - 17 Boats)
1. Incognito, J 121 40, Joe Brito, Bristol, RI, USA - 5 -1; 6
2. Cavalino, W-37 37, Mike Toppa, Newport, RI, USA - 2 -4; 6
3. Katahdin, Farr 40 40, Trevor W. Nelson, Hingham, MA, USA - 1 -6; 7
4. Tink, Eggemoggin 47 47, Jack LeFort, Jamestown, RI, USA - 3 -5; 8
5. Summer Grace, J 122 40, Kevin Kelley, Riverside, CT, USA - 6 -3; 9
PHRF 3 (PHRF - 16 Boats)
1. UPBEAT, J/99 32.6', Jeff Johnstone, Newport, RI, USA - 3 -2; 5
2. Divided Sky, Summit 35 35, Vincent & Kristina McAteer, East Greenwich, RI, USA - 2 -5; 7
3. Growth Spurt, J 109 35, John Greifzu, Jr., Darien, CT, USA - 5 -3; 8
4. Dark Star, sloop 32, Roger Lowlicht, Branford, CT, USA - 1 -8; 9
5. MAYHEM, J105 34.5', Douglas Stryker, Crownsville, MD, USA - 11 -1; 12
PHRF 4 (PHRF - 9 Boats)
1. Blackwing, Stuart Knockabout 28, Eric Hall, Bristol, RI, USA - 1 -3 -1; 5
2. The Hawk, Tripp 37, Oivind Lorentzen, stamford, CT, USA - 2 -2 -2; 6
3. Dirty Harry, J 29 29, Jack McGuire, Annapolis, MD, USA - 3 -1 -3; 7
4. SPRAY, Stuart Knockabout 28, Andrew McClatchy, North Kingstown, RI, USA - 5 -6 -4; 15
5. Sparkle Pony, Kirie Elite 37, Bill Finn, Milton, MA, USA - 4 -4 -8; 16
PHRF Non-Spinnaker (PHRF - 2 Boats)
1. Ponyo, Camden Class Knockabout 28, Paul Koch, East Greenwich, RI, USA - 1 -1 -1; 3
2. Star Dancer, Freedom 35 35, David Pedrick, Newport, RI, USA - 2 -2 -2; 6
Shields (One Design - 14 Boats)
1. Grace, Shields 30, John Burnham/ Reed Baer, Middletown, RI, USA - 2 -4 -4 -2 -3 -2 -1; 18
2. Jade, Sheilds 30, Josh Gilchrist, Portsmouth, R.I., USA - 6 -13 -1 -1 -2 -3 -7; 33
3. Tinky, Shields 30, Clayton Deutsch, Newport, RI, USA - 1 -3 -2 -3 -6 -7 -12; 34
4. Weetamoe, Shields 30, Peter Fernberger, Newport, RI, USA - 7 -9 -6 -5 -1 -5 -5; 38
5. Bit~O~Honey, Shields 30, Ken Deyett, Marion, MA, USA - 8 -2 -5 -8 -8 -6 -2; 39
PHRF 1 (PHRF - 4 Boats)
1. IRIE 2, Kerr 55 55, Brian Cunha, Newport, RI, USA - 2 -2 -1 -1; 6
2. OUTLIER, Botin 55 55'9, Harvey Jones, Nantucket, MA, USA - 1 -1 -2 -2; 6
3. PUGILIST, Marten 49 49, Dudley Johnson, Westerly, RI, USA - 4 -4 -3 -3; 14
4. Laura, Westerly Marine RP 60 60, Kip Curren, Newport, RI, USA - 3 -3 -4 -4; 14
IC37 (One Design - 14 Boats)
1. MENACE, IC37 37, HOWARD SPENCER, WHANGAMATA, NEW ZEALAND, NZL - 5 -3 -1 -2 -6; 17
2. New Wave, IC37 37, Steve Liebel, Tampa, FL, USA - 4 -2 -2 -4 -8; 20
3. Defiant, IC37 37, Terry McLaughlin, Toronto, ON, CAN - 9 -1 -6 -5 -1; 22
4. NYYC IC Team (Gamecock), IC37 37, Peter McClennen, Newport, RI, USA - 3 -4 -8 -1 -11; 27
5. O-J, IC37 37, Jay Cross, houston, TX, USA - 7 -11 -7 -3 -3; 31
12 Metre - Traditional (One Design - 4 Boats)
1. Columbia, 12 Metre 69.6, Kevin Hegarty Anthony Chiurco, Newport, RI, USA - 2 -2 -1 -1; 6
2. American Eagle, 12 Meter 67.6, Robert Morton, Middletown, RI, USA - 3 -1 -3 -2; 9
3. Weatherly, 12m 68, Steve Eddleston, Bristol, RI, USA - 1 -3 -4 -4; 12
4. Nefertiti (T), 12 Metre 68, Jack Klinck, Concord, MA, USA - 4 -4 -2 -3; 13
ORC D (ORC - 9 Boats)
1. Teamwork, J 122 40, Team Syndicate, Lexington, NC, USA - 1 -1 -1 -3 -1; 7
2. ZUUL, Aerodyne 38 38, Benedict Capuco, Alexandria, VA, USA - 2 -5 -2 -4 -2; 15
3. Escape Velocity II, Summit 40 40, Ben Chigier, Manchester, MA, USA - 4 -2 -4 -1 -5; 16
4. Leading Edge, J 122 40, Tom Sutton, Houston, TX, USA - 3 -3 -3 -5 -3; 17
5. Tarahumara, J122 40, Jack Gregg, Jamestown, RI, USA - 5 -4 -5 -2 -4; 20